Seven questions
to ask anyone who
sells you a trading bot.
Use this simple check to spot a fair, clear and safe offer, us included.
The seven questions
Ask these before you buy or sign up.
Does the seller show losing days, weeks and months as large as the gains?
Screenshots of green days are not a result. Ask for the worst day, the worst month and the longest stretch without a new high, in the same size as the net figure.
Our answer. Yes, and first. The worst day, the busted starts and the stress test sit next to the net result in the same size, and the check files let you recompute every day yourself. How we check the figures
Are commission and slippage included in every figure?
A result without costs is a different result. Ask which commission and how much slippage the figures assume; "net" alone means nothing.
Our answer. Yes. Every figure on this site includes commission and slippage: $1.90 per round trip and one tick of slippage.
Was it tested on data it was not tuned on?
Any rule set looks good on the data it was fitted to. Ask whether the rules were frozen before the test period, and whether small changes to the settings break the result.
Our answer. In part. The rules are frozen between announced updates, and the simulation runs the same rules from every start day of three years. The sizing was chosen on those same three years, so these figures are in-sample. The Bot Challenge shows one account day by day since November 2, 2026. What was simulated · Bot Challenge
Do you know who is behind it: name, company, country?
A real person with a company you can look up, an address and a tax number. No name, no company and a domain registered last month is the pattern the CFTC warns about.
Our answer. Ruben, founder. SmartKøb DK, Fanø, Denmark, CVR 39058162; address and email in the footer of every page. We get no commission when you buy or reset a prop account.
Does it run on your machine, or does it want your login?
Never give anyone the login of your prop account or your broker. A bot that needs it can trade, withdraw or lose your account without you.
Our answer. Your machine. It runs inside your own trading platform on your PC or VPS; we never see your prop-firm login, your funds or your orders. What runs where
Does it promise returns, a percent per month or results that cannot fail?
Nobody knows next month. A number for the future is the clearest warning sign there is.
Our answer. Never. Every figure we show is a hypothetical simulation with the disclosure next to it, the simulator shows the busted runs as well, and accounts can bust. Our disclosures
Can you test it before you commit, and get your money back if it is not for you?
A free way to check the claims before paying, and a plain refund rule after, in writing.
Our answer. The simulator and the check files are free before you pay. After: 14 days money back on your first payment, for everyone, no reason needed. Refund policy
How to use the seven questions
A seller who answers all seven in plain words, with something you can check, is rare. A seller who dodges one of them has told you what you needed to know.
Share this page with anyone who is about to pay for a bot. No names of other sellers here, on purpose: the questions work on every one of them, including us.
CFTC warning signs
The US futures regulator, the CFTC, says to watch for these red flags.
The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission published a customer advisory on AI trading bots after a case in which a bot seller showed fake results from demo accounts. Its warning signs, in short:
Sure or unusually high returns
Claims that the software foresees the market
Nobody you can check
Referral bonuses
Pressure from strangers
Read the advisory: CFTC customer advisory "AI Won't Turn Trading Bots into Money Machines". The CFTC is not affiliated with us; the advisory is public information.